Start With Cost Per Job, Not Cost Per Lead
A lead is an enquiry. A job is money in the bank. The gap between the two is where most marketing spend disappears.
Roofing Trades Journal put it well with two worked examples. Buy 20 leads at £20 each, turn four of them into booked jobs, and each job has cost you £100. Spend £250 on a month of directory membership, win two jobs from it, and each one has cost £125. The cheaper-looking option isn't always the cheaper one.
So before you judge any source, write down three numbers for last month: what you spent on it, how many enquiries it sent, and how many of those you priced up and won. Most roofers can answer the first, guess the second, and have no idea about the third.
Referrals and Word of Mouth
Still the best roofing leads you'll get. The customer already trusts you before they ring, and they're usually less interested in getting four quotes.
The problem is you can't turn it up. A stormy week and the phone doesn't stop. A dry August and it's silent, and there's nothing you can do about either.
Worth knowing too: a referral today still Googles you. Their neighbour gives them your name, they search it, look at your reviews and your website, and then decide whether to ring. Word of mouth gets you shortlisted. What they find online decides whether you get the call.
Trade Directories
Checkatrade, TrustATrader and the like. The vetting badge carries weight with homeowners, and a decent profile with good reviews can bring in steady work.
On cost, Roofing Trades Journal quotes one national directory at about £30 a month plus VAT for a basic plan without sales leads, usually on a 12-month term. Plans that send you leads cost more.
The catch is that you're renting. Your profile sits on a page next to your competitors, and the reviews you collect there live on their site, not yours. Stop paying and that profile stops working for you. A directory can be worth having, but it shouldn't be the only place your reputation lives.
Bought Roofing Leads
Lead sellers come in two types, and the difference matters more than the price.
Shared leads go to several roofers at once. The homeowner hears from three or four of you, it becomes a race to ring first, and the job usually goes to whoever's cheapest.
Exclusive leads go to you alone. They cost more. Roofing Trades Journal found one seller charging from £20 per exclusive roofing lead and from £130 per booked appointment.
Quality varies a lot between sellers. Some leads are people who've already booked someone, some just want a rough price, and some numbers don't answer. Bought leads can be a useful way to fill gaps in the diary. Just track them by cost per job, not cost per lead, or they'll look better than they are.
Google Ads
Google Ads put you at the top of the results today, and the demand is there. "roofer near me" gets around 33,100 searches a month in the UK. The average click on it costs about £5.29, with top-of-page bids running from roughly £4 to £17.
Demand also moves with the weather. Searches for "emergency roofer" ran at 720 a month last October and November, and fell to 90 in July this year. If you're going to run ads, autumn and winter are when the phone's most likely to ring from them.
Two things to watch. Ads stop the moment you stop paying, so you're not building anything. And a badly set-up campaign will happily spend your money on clicks from outside your area, or for work you don't do. If you run ads, someone needs to check the search terms report every week.